一千萬個為什麽

搜索

我們能否將大屠殺歸類為希特勒的戰爭時期戰略錯誤?

我們能否將大屠殺歸類為希特勒的戰爭時期戰略錯誤之一?

最佳答案

The German and Austrian Jewish population was about 750,000, of which three quarters were exterminated. Whereas the total German population was about 70 million. But 1941, when the extermination program began the number of Jewish forced labourers in German was 60,000, compared to the 2,000,000 foreign labourers (Fremdarbeiter) [source]. The Nazis decided that this was not an economic impediment to the Holocaust. Furthermore, in regions where the sudden absence of Jewish Labour would have been a problem they delayed the process to allow for their replacement.

It seems logical that the movement from forced labour to Extermination through Labour and the Holocaust of the Jewish population would have lead to costs (from the inefficiency of moving skilled workers to hard labour, to the expenses of diverting effort to commit to commit these awful crimes). These must have been the disruptions the Nazis had in mind and saw as no economic reason not to proceed. I will say the Jews brought from conquered lands for forced labour probably would have been an overall benefit to the German war effort, but I'm not including that as the "holocaust" as I'm assuming the alternative the questioner has in mind is assigning these foreign Jews to the Fremdarbeiter system anyway.

所以不,這不是一個巨大的戰略錯誤。我沒有考慮其他角度,比如它對核計劃的影響,但從原始經濟角度來看,納粹似乎沒有因其可怕的罪行而受到懲罰。因此,總而言之,大屠殺雖然是歷史上最可怕的危害人類罪之一,但並不像OP可能懷疑的那樣具有經濟意義。

轉載註明原文: 我們能否將大屠殺歸類為希特勒的戰爭時期戰略錯誤?